TV critics' verdict on programmes - including BBC4’s one-off documentary Russell Brand On the Road - broadcast on 12 December 2007

Russell Brand On the Road, BBC4
“It’s not especially illuminating, and mostly totally infuriating. And yet -Russell Brand is hard not to like.”
Sam Wollaston, The Guardian

Russell Brand On the Road, BBC4
“ -funny, engaging, moving, mucky and intelligent (yes, really all those things.)”
Tim Teeman, The Times

Russell Brand On the Road, BBC4
“Loose and self-indulgent and prone to metaphysical ramblings, Russell Brand on the Road mirrored the qualities of Kerouac’s book but was a good deal funnier.”
Thomas Sutcliffe, The Independent

Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS? One Year On, BBC2
“ -Robinson (perhaps understandably) proved rather better at diagnosing the problems than at suggesting a cure.”
James Walton, The Times

Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS? - One Year On, BBC2
“One thing became clear as this programme unfolded. Fixing the NHS is only addressing the symptoms. If Gerry Robinson has got some spare time next year, he should try fixing the Government.”
Matt Baylis, Daily Express

Can Gerry Robinson Fix the NHS? - One Year On, BBC2
“The NHS wastes money, is sinking under its owned botched bureaucracy, right? So, why [ -] did my sympathy go to the managers and bureaucrats, while my bewilderment was saved for Sir Gerry and his directionless bluster?”
Tim Teeman, The Times

The Secret Millionaire, Channel 4
“Chaudry’s slow reconnection with his roots added a definite and often touching edge to what would otherwise have been a fairly standard episode.”
James Walton, The Times

On a Tightrope, More 4
“Thanks to Lom -we glimpsed a culture we had never encountered, and if the Chinese government has its way, probably won’t again.”
Patricia Wynn Davies, The Times

The Pink Floyd Story: Which One’s Pink?, BBC1
“They are honest and thoughtful, a bit shy -Sure, there is a smugness there, as there is in their music. It’s certainly not hard to empathise with Johnny Rotten and his famous “I hate Pink Floyd” T-shirt.”
Sam Wollaston, The Guardian

The Spice Girls On Trial, Five
“This is not a likeable documentary, however. No horses’ mouths this time, just rent-a-gob donkeys.”
Sam Wollaston, The Guardian

The End of the World Cult, Channel 4
“His acolytes looked on in creepy adoration, like dogs waiting for a tid-bit to be dropped. The end of the world has now been rescheduled, due to God’s lack of interest in the first one.”
Thomas Sutcliffe, The Independent

Topics