Case involving Richard Gadd’s hit scripted series to be heard in front of a jury in California

Netflix will head to court in the US next year after an American judge confirmed a date for Fiona Harvey’s $150m (£114m) lawsuit against the streamer’s hit drama, Baby Reindeer.
Harvey first sued for damages in 2024 and was subsequently allowed to pursue the case on the grounds of defamation, after the show was billed as a “true story.”
The process stalled as Netflix appealed the decision but Judge Gary Klausner has now set a court date of 18 May, 2027 for the case to be heard. The trial will include a jury and will be located in LA.
Harvey’s US lawyer Richard Roth described his client as being “delighted” and told The Times that she had faced “terrible mental anguish” over the past two years.
“We’re very excited to finally have the chance to get justice and to get this in front of a jury,” he said.
Harvey, a former lawyer, and her team are seeking $150m in actual and compensatory damages, as well as a share of profits from the show.
She has claimed that the drama falsely showed her as a convicted stalker and has deeply affected her life.
Netflix has denied defaming Harvey, arguing in court filings that the events from the show were substantially true and that her reputation had been damaged prior to the show’s launch.
The streamer added that Harvey had not been able to point to a provably false statement of fact about her.
Lawyers from both sides had asked for the trial to take place in July 2027, but judge Klausner opted for an earlier date.
Background & context
The hearing will likely explore the show’s opening episode, which begins with the line “This is a true story”. In his 2024 ruling, Klausner noted that this allows viewers to take the subsequent story as factual.
He added at the time that while Harvey’s “purported actions are reprehensible,” those depicted in the show are worse than what Harvey was accused of in reality.
The hit Netflix drama follows the story of creator Richard Gadd – who is not a defendant in the lawsuit – and his experiences of being stalked by a character called Martha, allegedly based on Harvey.
In the series, Martha sexually assaults Gadd and is later convicted and jailed for stalking. Harvey argues that she has not been convicted of a crime.
“There is a major difference between stalking and being convicted of stalking in a court of law,” the judge wrote in his 2024 ruling.
Klausner continued that the series made “no effort” to fact check or disguise the identity of Harvey, who was quickly discovered online after the series aired in April 2024. While she was never named in the series, she was identified via social media posts.
In his 2024 defence to the lawsuit, Gadd outlined that he did report Harvey to the police and that she received a harassment warning but was not criminally sentenced.
Further, he has said that the Netflix show was not supposed to be a “beat-for-beat recounting” but rather a fictionalised retelling. He has also stated that “Martha Scott is not Fiona Harvey.”
Netflix has previously said it would “defend this matter vigorously and to stand by Richard Gadd’s right to tell his story.”
The hit Netflix drama was produced by BBC Studios-owned Clerkenwell Films has clocked more than 100m views worldwide since its debut in April 2024.
The streamer initially appealed Harvey’s lawsuit in October 2024, forcing the original trial date of May 2025 to be cancelled. A subsequent appeal was rejected last month, leading to confirmation of the 18 May trial date.
Broadcast International has contacted Netflix for comment.
No comments yet