“I Am Helen is as harrowing in its unerring accuracy as the rest. By all means wait to watch it, but do watch it”

I Am Helen, Channel 4
“I Am Helen is as harrowing in its unerring accuracy as the rest. By all means wait to watch it, but do watch it. Helen (Nicola Coughlan, in a superb everywoman performance) is five years into a relationship with Steve (Joe Cole). They are engaged and happy – or, as is generally the case in [Dominic] Savage’s determinedly realistic universe, happy enough. We open with them going to bed together and starting to have sex, something they have obviously done many times before. This time, however, the mood shifts and he begins to choke her and doesn’t desist as soon as she starts to struggle and say no. It’s in those few moments between the starting and the stopping that essentially all of the drama lives. The next 90 minutes (divided into two parts) are an exploration of what they mean – for Helen, for Steve, for the couple, for us, for society and even, perhaps, for the future if we cannot close the gaps between the sexes, between communication and miscommunication, consent and compliance, reality and fantasy, needs and wants, love and service before they become gulfs that separate us for ever.”
Lucy Mangan, The Guardian
“As has always been the case with this series, the dialogue is naturalistic, almost to a fault. You get the sense that this would work spectacularly as a play, really dialling up the claustrophobia and terror between Helen and Steve. That said, it’s plenty tense on screen. One sequence, in which Helen has a small window of time in which to pack her belongings and get out of there, plays out like a horror movie. It’s never so obvious as to bang you over the head with it, but the manosphere certainly figures in this story. Savage does well, though, to keep his lens tight on the specificities of Helen and Steve as a couple in crisis rather than make an attempt at some state-of-the-nation polemic. The series says enough as it is.”
Annabel Nugent, The Independent
“While the sexist chats between Steve and his workplace “bro” (Nick Preston) feel inauthentic, the scenes between Steve and Helen – his eruptions of anger followed by wheedling back into her affection – ring true. “I’m terrified I’m going to do something if you go,” he tells Helen when she attempts to end the relationship, a piece of emotional blackmail that will feel horribly familiar to many women. It’s hard for anyone to admit that they’re in a relationship like this. I Am Helen might just help someone out there to recognise the warning signs and find the resolve to get out.”
Anita Singh, Telegraph
“It’s a testament to Cole that he manages to make Steve in some ways sympathetic and not just a one-dimensional toxic male. He tells his unpleasant friend at work, a man who thinks women need a slap to keep them in line, that he really does love Helen, he wants to marry her, but he doesn’t seem to realise that his love is controlling and conditional, and that porn has polluted what healthy sex means to him. He does seem to be a man lost, torn between his real feelings and what the manosphere preaches.”
Carol Midgley, The Times
Young, British and Tradwife, BBC1
“In many ways, it is a hugely frustrating watch – mainly because you want to see 12 hours of close interrogation of each wife and each husband (separately) by a trained psychotherapist, and in-depth interviews with parents and friends who knew them before and after marriage and who have no compunction about burning bridges if they need to. But this, of course, is not possible. This is an hour that is designed to provoke further thought and inspire, hopefully, more detailed investigations. Jay – a formidable presence and fearless in her questioning of the men, though perhaps too careful with the women – does great work in showcasing the different facets of the movement and hinting at all the complicated possible motives.”
Lucy Mangan, The Guardian



















No comments yet